Mays Lake is west of Square Lake within the grounds of Camp Wilder.
Northern Pike: above average abundance, average size.
Largemouth Bass: average abundance, smaller than average size.
Bluegill: above average abundance, smaller than average size.
There is no boat access to this lake. The entire shoreline is owned by Camp Wilder.
Fishing is limited to Camp Wilder guests.
This is a small lake with good water quality. Fishing was limited to shore angling by Camp Wilder campers.